Showing posts with label companies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label companies. Show all posts

Thursday, August 1, 2019

Variable Annuity Expense Levels Might Be Converging

Jay Singh (Photo: Hedgeness) Jay Singh (Photo: Hedgeness)

Note: This article was updated after initial publication to reflect information from Hedgeness about 2018 and 2019 data comparability.

Big U.S. variable annuity issuers might be using more similar expense structures for popular living benefits riders.

Hedgeness Inc., a Chicago-based financial services data analytics company, has included data supporting that possibility in a new batch of variable annuity living benefits rider rating data.

(Related: Unexpected Ways to Reduce RMDs, Optimize Retirement Cash Flow)

Hedgeness included 13 issuers in its latest rating table, up from seven last year.

The firm uses a proprietary formula to calculate expense and benefits figures.

For 2019, the overall expense charge levels ranged from 2.64% up to 3.61%, and the benefits value figures ranged from 18.49 up to 41.31.

For 2018, the range was 2.69% to 3.49% for expense charges, and 26.30 to 36.36 for benefits value figures.

We compared the median figures for benefits and riders for the companies with riders that appeared in both tables.

The median exchange charge level held steady at 3.24%, according to ThinkAdvisor calculations.

The median benefits level for the seven companies with riders that appeared in both tables increased to 37.01%. That’s up 25% from the 2018 median, 29.58%.

We also looked at how much the gaps between the highest and lowest values changed between 2018 and this year, for the seven companies with riders that appeared in both tables.

The gap between the highest expense figure and the lowest shrank to just 11% this year, from about 30% in 2018.

The gap between the highest benefits value figure and the lowest held steady at about 38%.

The figures appear to show that typical expense levels stayed about the same, but riders with especially high or low expense levels moved toward the median.

Typical benefits levels increased significantly, but companies made no obvious push to offer benefits that were more in line with what the other companies in the 2018 Hedgeness table were offering.

Resources

A link to the new Hedgeness variable annuity rating data is available here.

— Read Why That MYGA Rate Is So Hot, on ThinkAdvisor.

— Connect with ThinkAdvisor Life/Health on Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter.

Thursday, May 2, 2019

Judge Greenlights NY Regulators' Lawsuit Against Federal Agency Over Fintech Charters

A customer uses an Apple iPhone to make a payment on a Square device. (Photo: David Paul Morris/Bloomberg)

A federal judge on Thursday rejected a motion from an office within the U.S. Treasury Department to dismiss a lawsuit from the New York State Department of Financial Services seeking to prevent the federal government from issuing certain bank charters to financial technology companies.

The state agency, which regulates financial institutions in New York, is suing the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency over a decision to essentially label fintech companies as banks, saying it will diminish its power to regulate the activities of those entities.

Acting DFS Superintendent Linda Lacewell celebrated the decision in a statement, saying it will give the agency an opportunity to argue why those companies should not be federally chartered as banks since federal regulations on those institutions haven’t been as comprehensive as state actions.

“The court has recognized the expertise of DFS and other state banking regulators and the significant role we play in regulating nonbank financial services, promoting innovative fintech products, helping to achieve a level playing field for regulated banking institutions, and most importantly, protecting consumers,” Lacewell said. “DFS, which was created in response to the financial crisis, will continue to lead and fill any and all voids that misguided federal policy decisions create.”

It’s the second time DFS has sued the OCC over its decision to allow fintech companies that do not receive deposits to seek special-purpose national bank charters. The first lawsuit was thrown out last year after a judge said it wasn’t ripe for review. The OCC had not started accepting applications from fintech companies for those charters at the time.

Now, U.S. District Judge Victor Marrero of the Southern District of New York wrote Thursday that the agency’s challenge to the OCC decision is ready for review since the office announced it would start accepting those applications last July.

“As a result of the Fintech Charter Decision, New York State’s regulations for over ‘600 non-bank financial services firms’ are all at risk of becoming null and void,” Marrero said.

The issue of the case is over how financial institutions are regulated between the federal government and the states. Entities chartered by a state are generally also subject to federal regulations. But those chartered by the federal government are largely supervised by the OCC alone, meaning that regulations promulgated by a state agency, like DFS, may not apply.

As of now, entities that do not receive deposits, like payday lenders and other fintech companies, are left largely up to the states to regulate. Marrero wrote that, based on the claims from DFS, there’s a real possibility that fintech companies could seek a federal charter to avoid state oversight because of the decision from the OCC.

“Based on DFS’s allegations about the threats of federal preemption and the unique characteristics of the dual banking system, DFS faces the current risk that entities may, at any moment, leave its supervision to seek greener pastures,” Marrero wrote.

The OCC has argued in filings seeking to dismiss the lawsuit that its decision to allow applications for federal charters from fintech companies was based on its interpretation of a section of the National Banking Act. The law says that a financial institution can apply for a federal charter if it’s in the “business of banking.”

DFS has argued that fintech companies are not in the “business of banking” because they don’t receive deposits. The OCC has argued that the “business of banking” definition is satisfied by other activities of those companies, like lending money. Marrero, in the decision, sided with the former argument.

“The Court finds that the term ‘business of banking,’ as used in the NBA, unambiguously requires receiving deposits as an aspect of the business,” Marrero wrote.

He noted in the decision that the OCC has never used the same argument regarding the “business of banking” to issue charters to other nondepository entities. In fact, Marrero wrote, when the OCC has sought to issue charters to such institutions in the past, Congress has amended the National Banking Act to allow the action.

Marrero did, however, dismiss one section of the lawsuit from DFS alleging that the fintech decision from the OCC violated the Tenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. He said that, while DFS had standing to raise such a claim, it had failed properly state one in its complaint.

A spokesman for the OCC said they were still reviewing the decision Tuesday and declined to comment further.